NOTE: This is the same review as done on the
DVD. Picture and sound quality notes have been added.
Who would've thought that Edward Scissorhands would switch to sharp barber blades? Who would've thought that he'd be an angry, singing monster bent on revenge? That's kind of what "Sweeney Todd" becomes under the direction of Tim Burton and the acting of Johnny Depp.
“Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street” is now available on Blu-ray.
Kidding aside, "Sweeney Todd" is no Edward Scissorhands, and Depp puts in another fine performance as the English barber bent on payback. I couldn't help but to imagine the teaming of Burton & Depp taking the sweet character of Scissorhands and turning him into a monster. But they didn't, really. "Sweeney Todd" has been around a lot longer than Scissorhands, and is one of Stephen Sondheim and Hugh Wheeler's most famous Broadway musicals. I've joked to friends that Broadway will turn almost any story into a high-kicking musical. Think "Mask" or Monty Python. Who would've thought that a horrifying tale could be turned into a bloody, graphic, and sometimes funny musical show? Sondheim, Wheeler and Harold Prince did, and staged the show for many years with actress Angela Lansbury (Mrs. Potts in Disney's "Beauty and the Beast" for Heaven's sake!), and it's one of Broadway's enduring shows.
It's surprising that the film version took so long to get to the big screen. Under Burton's direction, Dante Ferretti's production design, Depp and Carter's acting and surprising singing chops, the film version arrives on the scene nicely. In watching the movie, I felt as though I was transported to the old 1960s movie musicals. The direction, the camerawork and overall feel of the movie is reminiscent of the "serious" musicals of that time. "Oliver!" (1968) comes to mind. Also imagine if "Mary Poppins" (1964) went very dark, and you get the idea. Sure, everyone sings and dances (though limited), but the darkness of the story and the film's atmosphere tells you that this isn't a standard musical movie.
The first hour or so of "Sweeney Todd" is lovely. I got into the dark and Burtonesque world of "Sweeney Todd." Very moody, very dark, very sinister, this is London on hallucinogens. Not being a fan of extensive gore, I found myself asking, "So when does the bloodletting begin?" The first hour is well-paced and sets up Todd's bloodlust, and the love of Carter's Mrs. Lovett has for him. Depp and Carter actually sing quite well (though I wonder how much sweetening was done in post-production...apparently they've never sung before) and Burton sets up the dark feel of the film well. I enjoyed the opening title sequence. Bloody and moody, but just right. At least there is no throat slashing. We're also introduced, via a short scene, to the evil Judge Turpin (Alan Rickman) and his minion, Beadle Bamford (Timothy Spall). Everything is bloody-well terrific so far.
I know it's contradictory to say, but I found myself squeamish by the time the first slashing begins. Indeed, the movie is about the Demon Barber of Fleet Street, so I knew I what I was getting myself into. I've been warned by the title itself! Burton handles the gore with his typical artistry, making the slashing elegant to an extent. I guess I so much enjoyed how Burton and the cast set up the story in the first hour, that the bloodletting is shocking. Perhaps that was done purposely (I never saw the stage show, so I don't know how the story was originally structured). The slashing is probably no less horrifying than gory scenes from today's gore porn films. From what I heard and read about "Sweeney Todd," the graphic scenes were done tastefully as possible. I thought they were pretty graphic. This is not to say that the film turned my off at this point. I still enjoyed it. I just thought that it shifted gears pretty quickly with the gore and storyline.
The plot is simple and to the point. Depp's wife and child are taken away from him by the corrupt Judge Turpin. Depp is sent away for years, only to come back to London with revenge in his heart. He's become so bent on revenge that it consumes him. Quite a contrast to his innocent and loving image we see in the musical flashback. What seems to drag the film's pacing down are the love song scenes with Anthony Hope (Jamie Campbell Bower) and Johanna (Jayne Wisener). Of course, without those scenes, there's no real payoff in the film.
I was hoping for a bit more humanity to Todd's character. I didn't root for him, despite his loss of his family in the early part of the film. He's so dark, so sinister, that I actually enjoyed Rickman's villain better. Depp steers a little bit of Jack Sparrow into his role of Todd. Depp is extremely talented as an actor, having more range than many actors today. In this role, though, he seems more in tune with Jack Sparrow, though. He scowls a lot. Also noteworthy is Sasha Baron Cohen's operatic barber character.
The highlight of the film is Helena Bonham Carter. She's played some oddball characters over the years in gritty films like "Fight Club" (1999), but she's been splendid in recent years in Burton's "The Corpse Bride" and "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005). There's a sweetness and caring to Carter in the role of Mrs. Lovett. Despite the fact she runs the worst bakery in London and is conniving, she still has a heart. Maybe a misguided heart, but a heart no less.
The Blu-ray is a nice improvement over the DVD, which was excellent its own right. The picture quality of Dariusz Wolski's dark and moody cinematography and shows very nicely in HD. The color palette of black and red is revealed with sharp detail. The soundtrack quality is very good in Dolby TrueHD, though my ears must be playing tricks on me. I did an unscientific A/B test between the DVD and Blu-ray versions and found that I prefer the Dolby Digital version. The Dolby Digital version sounds a bit richer and full. The Dolby TrueHD versions sounds a bit restrained in comparison. Indeed the Blu-ray has a higher bit rate and should technically sound better. I'm not sure if perhaps the DVD and Blu-ray were possibly mastered in different facilities, whereby the audio encoding was tweaked in the process. I'm merely mentioning what I heard between the two soundtracks. They both sound very good and each sounds like they've been heavily dubbed, especially once the actors begin to sing. The sound reminds me of the old 1960s epic musicals in how they were dubbed.
Burton's version of "Sweeney Todd" is often times typical Burton. He likes the color of black and he likes moodiness. His work has become its own cliché. I recently caught a video on You Tube of writer/director Kevin Smith ripping into Burton's artsy personality. It's true that Burton has his own style (in movies and with his public persona). I've enjoyed many of his films, despite Smith's funny comments about him (of which I got laughs out of). Burton is Burton, and despite his now cliché ways of making his films, "Sweeney Todd" is an admirable addition to his credits.
Special thanks to Click Communications
Photos: © DreamWorks Pictures. All rights reserved.
|Blu-ray Quick Glimpse|